CLJ Coaching Life's Journey: Leadership Transformation
All insights

Leadership

How you show up is the message

9 min read|Article||Vanessa Hopkins, CPC, ELI-MP
Executive pausing before entering a leadership meeting

Every leader has a default setting. It shows up in the first thirty seconds of a meeting, in the tone of a message written at the end of a long day, in the face you make when a project slips. Your team reads that setting constantly, and they calibrate to it.

Most leaders significantly underestimate how closely they are being read. The higher your position, the more your smallest signals get magnified and interpreted. A distracted glance at your phone during someone's update is a two-second event for you and a week-long story for them.

Two kinds of energy

Energy Leadership work distinguishes between catabolic energy, which is contracting and draining, and anabolic energy, which is expanding and constructive. Catabolic leadership is not always loud. It can look like quiet withdrawal, sarcasm, or a leader who solves every problem themselves because it is faster. Anabolic leadership is not always warm either. It can be a direct, uncomfortable conversation delivered from a place of genuine care.

"Catabolic energy is draining, resisting, and contracting. Anabolic energy is fueling, healing, and growth-oriented."

Bruce D Schneider, Energy Leadership

Neither state is a personality. Both are available to you in any given hour, which is exactly what makes this workable. Nobody is asking you to become a different person. The ask is that you notice which one you brought and whether it serves the moment.

The science of contagion

There is a physiological reason your state travels. Research on emotional contagion shows that people unconsciously mirror the affect of those around them, and that the mirroring runs strongest from the highest-status person in the room outward.

"Emotions spread from person to person, and the emotional state of the leader has a disproportionate effect because everyone watches the leader."

Daniel Goleman, Richard Boyatzis and Annie McKee, Primal Leadership

This is why the composed leader who is privately annoyed rarely fools anyone. The words say one thing, the nervous system says another, and people trust the nervous system.

The cost of the default

When a leader's default runs contracting for long enough, it stops being a mood and becomes a culture. Research on attrition found that the environment leaders create outweighs even compensation.

"A toxic corporate culture is by far the strongest predictor of industry-adjusted attrition, and is more than 10 times more important than compensation in predicting turnover."

Donald Sull, Charles Sull and Ben Zweig, MIT Sloan Management Review, 2022

More recent work has extended the finding beyond retention into health. In its 2024 State of the Global Workplace report, Gallup found that people who feel their manager is unengaged or negative report levels of daily stress and negative emotion comparable to being unemployed. The manager relationship is not one factor among many. For most employees it is the workplace.

"Managers have as much influence on employees' mental health as their partner, and more than their doctor or therapist."

The Workforce Institute at UKG, Mental Health at Work study, 2023

People rarely leave over a single conversation. They leave over the accumulated experience of how it felt to work for someone.

Presence is a decision

The leaders who land well are not the ones with the best natural temperament. They are the ones who decide, before walking in, what the room needs from them and whether they are currently able to provide it. When the answer is no, they take two minutes to reset rather than spending two weeks repairing the damage.

Two minutes sounds trivial next to the size of the problems on your calendar. It is also the difference between a team that heard a hard truth and a team that heard a threat.

A practice for the next meeting

  • Name your state before the meeting: settled, rushed, defensive, curious.
  • Decide what the moment actually requires: challenge, steadiness, or space.
  • Ask what you are assuming about the people walking in, and whether you have checked it.
  • Close the gap on purpose rather than hoping the room will not notice.
  • Afterward, ask one person what the meeting felt like. Treat their answer as data, not debate.

Your presence is already communicating. The only question is whether you chose the message.

Strengthen how you lead.

Explore executive coaching designed around your leadership context and goals.